Sauerkraut Grilled Cheese Sandwich

I spent my childhood years in the Yukon, and boy did I learn how to winter well. Truthfully, I love it; a slow season to embrace your inner homebody, settle into kitchen projects and reflect on what is important.

Three decades after my Yukon upbringing and I’m still curating that cozy life, like sipping an Earl Grey floral latte while curled up with a favourite cookbook. From hosting a soup swap with friends to long walks on the frozen lake, I know that a simple, analog lifestyle is my kind of luxury.

The cold months are ideal for finding joy in simple pleasures, like today’s sauerkraut grilled cheese sandwich recipe. Salty. Tangy. Crispy. Cheesy – this recipe showcases how a Ukrainian Canadian does comfort food in winter.

In Praise of the Sauerkraut Grilled Cheese

This sandwich is peak January snacking (lunching?). On the coldest of days, I keep a cast iron pan on the back of stove, and as the family trickles home from school/work/gym in the afternoon, I toast melty cheese sandwiches for all. Cozy? yes indeed.

I keep a stash of sliced bread -rustic and whole grain- in the freezer to facilitate this quick bite, and the rest comes together with whatever cheese and condiments I have in the fridge. Sauerkraut keeps forever, so I always have a jar on hand.

The sauerkraut/apple/Gruyere combination is a favourite of ours (think: Ruben sandwich, but simplified). It’s tangy and good for your gut. Pair it with a bowl of Borscht, and you have a gorgeous winter meal.

Grilled Cheese 101

I’ll try to keep this short, but there are a few kitchen tips that help create a kicking grilled cheese:

  • Hearty Bread. you want two slices that can hold up to the fillings. I like a rustic country loaf, sourdough or hearty whole grain bread.
  • Cast Iron Pan. It makes the best crust. Allow time for it to heat properly. More on cooking with cast iron.
  • Mayonnaise for Golden Crust. Yes, using mayo instead of butter on the outside of the bread will give you an overall better toasting. Butter will burn too quickly and the cheese won’t have enough time to melt properly.
  • Watch the Salt. If you’re using a salty cheese (aged cheddar, for example), use unsalted butter on the bread. And always balance out the sandwich with a bold mustard, chutney, even a drizzle of hot honey.

Variations on the Sauerkraut Grilled Cheese

Bread, cheese and sauerkraut are really all you need for this comforting bite, but here are a few ideas for playing around.

  • Hot mustard. I love a hot condiment with this sandwich. Grainy mustard is my go-to. Horseradish is fantastic as well. A spicy tomato chutney might be great too.
  • Bacon. For a breakfast grilled cheese tuck a little bacon into the sandwich. Don’t go overboard or it get too salty.
  • Fruit. Thin apple or pear slices bring a lovely sweetness to the sandwich. Choose Russet or Granny Smith apples and slice them very thin.
  • Smoked meat. With corned beef or pastrami for a Ruben-inspired sandwich.

To Serve: Since I’ve got the pan on the stove, I’ll fry up a few slices of kielbasa to go with the sandwich. Pickles are another great option.

Love Hot Sandwiches? Bookmark this decadent Asparagus & Lobster Grilled Cheese to try in the springtime.

Sauerkraut Grilled Cheese Sandwich

A lovely little winter lunch recipe, satisfying cravings for all things cheesy, crunchy and tangy. Sauerkraut is the hero of this sandwich; a pantry staple that pairs perfectly with mild cheese and tart apples.
4.86 from 14 votes
Print Pin Rate
Course: Lunches
Cuisine: Ukrainian
Keyword: Sandwich
Essential Ingredient: Cheese, Sauerkraut
Prep Time: 5 minutes
Cook Time: 10 minutes
Total Time: 15 minutes
Servings: 1

Ingredients

  • 2 slices sourdough bread or other crusty bread
  • 2 teaspoons mayonnaise
  • 2 teaspoons unsalted butter softened
  • pinch celery seed optional
  • 1 teaspoon grainy mustard
  • 1/2 cup sauerkraut drained
  • 1 small tart apple Russet or Granny Smith
  • 4 slices mild, firm cheese Gruyere, Swiss or Emmental

Instructions

  • Preheat a medium size cast iron pan over medium heat.
  • Spread the two outer sides of the bread with mayonnaise. Spread one slice of the inside with butter and sprinkle with celery seed, if using. Spread the other side generously with mustard.
  • Place the sauerkraut on a clean napkin or tea towel and ring out the excess moisture. Arrange the kraut on one side of the bread.
  • Thinly slice the apple, then arrange the cheese and apple on top of the 'kraut, layering them together. Top with bread, mayo side out.
  • Carfully transfer the layered sandwich to the preheated skillet and reduce the heat to low. Place a small square of parchment paper on top of the sandwich and weigh it down with another pan to flatten it somewhat.
  • Toast the grilled cheese for about 5 minutes or until deeply golden. Flip and repeat. Watch for the cheese to be melted through.
  • Transfer the sandwich to a cutting board. Slice in half with a serrated knife and enjoy at once.

Trending: Cabbage!

I’m thrilled that cabbage is having a well-deserved moment right now. It’s affordable, accessible and versatile; everything we need in this economy.

In a stunning culinary journey across Eastern Europe, author Alissa Timoshkina celebrates the humble vegetable in her cookbook, Kapusta (literal translation: cabbage), devoting an entire chapter to the cruciferous green head. It’s a great resource for cabbage recipes, it you’re looking for inspiration.

More Cabbage Recipes on Simple Bites:

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




27 Comments

  1. 5 stars
    Exactly what I was looking for! Such a delicious combo of flavors! Used a cosmic crisp apple that I had on hand.

  2. 5 stars
    I never would have thought to pair sauerkraut with grilled cheese, but it makes so much sense. The tangy crunch must balance the rich, melted cheese perfectly, and the apple is a really nice touch. Definitely adding this to my list of cozy lunch ideas! Thanks fora sharing wwith Her Trees Online

  3. Thanks for sharing this valuable information. Gamers are always looking for fresh content, reviews, and updates, and Mee Games is a great place to explore more gaming-related topics. Keep up the good work!

  4. 5 stars
    This recipe looks wonderfully simple and authentic. I love how the umeboshi adds such a unique flavor to the rice. It reminds me how loteria nacional traditions also celebrate timeless favorites shared across generations.

  5. I never thought of adding sauerkraut to a grilled cheese but this actually makes so much sense. The tangy kraut with melted Gruyere and thin apple slices sounds like the perfect combo. I also had no idea mayo works better than butter for toasting the bread outside. Honestly this is the kind of quick cozy lunch I need on a lazy afternoon when I just want to take a break playing flappy bird online and meme flapper games. Thanks for sharing Aimee!

  6. I’m trying to understand how OK Win Game works. What are the steps for OKWin Game Login, registration, and password recovery? Also, are there any basic security checks users should know about before using OK Win Games?

  7. This totally matches that slow-winter comfort vibe you described from the Yukon — sauerkraut in a grilled cheese sounds like exactly the kind of cozy kitchen project I’d want on a cold day. I actually got a similar “let’s make something weird but perfect” feeling from poking around a Minecraft Recipe site lately, which is a funny contrast to real food, but both are kind of about winter survival in their own way.

  8. 5 stars
    Just made this sauerkraut grilled cheese, and wow! The tangy crunch really takes the classic to another level. It’s like a flavor wave hitting my taste buds! 🌊 This combo not only feels comforting but also has me thinking about how food can connect us in unexpected ways—like those space waves we’re all curious about. Thanks for sharing such an awesome recipe; can’t wait to make it again and maybe even pair it with some cool craft beer!

  9. This sauerkraut grilled cheese sounds absolutely delicious. I love how the tangy sauerkraut balances the rich melted cheese, and the tip about pressing the sandwich really helps get that golden crust. The apple addition is a lovely touch too. I will definitely be trying this recipe this weekend. Thanks for sharing such a comforting classic with a twist.

  10. 5 stars
    Sauerkraut in a grilled cheese only works if you squeeze it dry; otherwise the bread steams and the cheese never browns. Winter food is about that kind of small discipline. We cook the same skillet lunch at yacht day in Phuket when the weather keeps everyone in. A pinch of mustard in the butter is what keeps it from tasting like a Reuben without the meat.

  11. 5 stars
    What a delightful recipe! The tangy sauerkraut paired with melty cheese sounds like an irresistible twist on the classic grilled cheese. As someone who enjoys running games, I appreciate meals that fuel my energy while being comforting. Can’t wait to try this!

  12. CalcSolver Solve everyday math problems online with a simple calculator and step-by-step style tools for equations, percentages, fractions, algebra, finance, and schoolwork—fast, free, and easy to use for students, teachers, creators, and anyone who needs quick calculation help.

  13. Translate Image Translate text inside images online while keeping the original layout, colors, and visual style as much as possible—upload screenshots, comics, product photos, posters, or social media images, then get a cleaner translated version for work, study, travel, e-commerce, and global content creation.

  14. This recipe sounds great for a quick lunch! I’m always looking for easy ways to use what’s in the pantry, and I’ve got some mild cheddar that would be perfect. I might even try to clean up some old family photos with a photo enhancer while it’s cooking.